We are updating our website, some pages may appear outdated.
Logo
Impact Report 2025

Work for Impact emphasise fair work, job security, and real social impact for underrepresented communities worldwide.

Read the Report
Smiling person standing in a field

Customer Support Training

Course

A free training program for training CS reps with the skills, tools, and knowledge to delight customers and resolve issues.

Get Access

Hiring & Managing a remote CS Team

Featured Content

Learn how to find the best remote talent, onboard them effectively, and maximize the benefits of building a remote CS team.

Download e-Book
Refer with Impact

Bring your clients to Work for Impact and claim your Independent Contractor’s advantages.

Refer a Client
alt

AI & Automation in Finance: What You Need to Know Before Staffing Your Team

Posted on 18/11/2025
6 Minutes Read

Build a stronger finance team for the AI era. Learn why traditional hiring falls short and how a global talent partner helps you close the new skills gap.

Key Takeaways

  • The primary challenge for finance leaders isn’t technology; it’s a human skills gap. As AI automates technical tasks, the critical need is for professionals with "hybrid" skills like critical thinking, data storytelling, and strategic collaboration to translate AI-outputs into business strategy.
  • The old playbook for finding talent is broken. Training existing staff ("Build") is too slow and meets high cultural resistance, while hiring new, AI-native talent locally ("Buy") is hyper-expensive, high-risk, and faces a massive hiring gap.
  • Leading CFOs are breaking this false choice with a Strategic Global Talent Partner. This hybrid model builds a resilient, high-performing global team by combining AI-smart sourcing with a transparent, Fair Pay foundation, delivering exceptional value  and long-term stability

The hype around AI in finance and accounting has never been higher. Yet, for most finance leaders, there's a troubling gap between its promise and its reality.

A 2025 BCG survey of senior finance executives found the median ROI on AI initiatives is just 10%. Worse, nearly one-third report "limited or no gains."

Finance teams winning with AI aren't just buying better tech. They are building smarter, more human-centric teams. The challenge for these leaders is that the old methods of finance recruitment are failing to find them.

The Real AI Skills Gap: It's Not What You Think

As AI-powered finance automation solutions handle repetitive, technical tasks, the human work that remains is, by definition, the work AI cannot do. This level of automation frees your team from data-crunching to spend more time interpreting, validating, and storytelling. They are being elevated from data processors to true strategic partners, translating AI's output into actionable business strategy.

This shift is creating a new class of "hybrid" roles that blend deep finance expertise with data science, technology, and governance. These new roles include:

  • Governance & Ethics Roles: AI Auditors, AI Compliance Specialists, and AI Ethics Specialists focused on ensuring safe, accurate, and ethical use of AI in your finance processes.
  • Technology & Systems Roles: Financial Systems Architects, Orchestration Architects, and AI Model Developers focused on designing and deploying AI-powered agents and workflows.
  • Strategy & Collaboration Roles: AI-Enhanced Investment Analysts, Human-AI Collaboration Leaders, and Conversation Designers focused on driving effective strategic use of AI.

These new roles create a profound skills gap against existing finance staff. The new, high-demand skills aren't just technical; they are actually deeply human:

  • Critical Thinking and Judgment: The ability to question an AI's output, validate its assumptions and interpret its findings.
  • Data Storytelling: The skill of translating complex data into a clear, actionable strategy for non-financial stakeholders.
  • Strategic Collaboration: The expertise to work across the business, integrating AI insights to drive growth and efficiency.

The challenge for leaders in hiring for tech skills finance is clear: You cannot find these hybrid professionals using the same old hiring playbook.

The "Build vs. Buy" Trap

Finance leaders are feel trapped by two bad options to address this gap:

  1. Build (Train): A slow, 12-24 month process with high cultural resistance and no guarantee of success.
  2. Buy (Hire): An expensive, high-risk gamble in a hyper-competitive local market, with a 50% hiring gap for AI-native talent and catastrophic bad-hire risks.

The table below takes a deeper look at both options:

Strategy Primary Tactic Average Cost Time-to-Impact Pros Cons
BUILD Upskill existing staff via internal/external training programs. Low: ~$15,231 per employee on average. Slow: 12-24 months for deep cultural adoption. Leverages invaluable domain expertise; high employee loyalty. High cultural resistance; slow to acquire new skills.
BUY Hire new, full-time AI-native talent (e.g., data scientists). Extreme: $238k-$300k+ annual salary, plus recruitment fees. Slow: 9-10 week average time-to-fill, plus onboarding/ramp time. Injects new "AI-native" DNA and skills into the team. Extreme cost; 50% hiring gap, catastrophic bad-hire risk

Both paths are too slow, too expensive and too risky. They are options from an old model that struggles to solve new-world problems. Trying to future-proof your finance department with this model is like trying to build a high-performance car with a hammer. It’s time for a different model.

A Smarter Way to Build Your Global Team

The Smarter Way: A Strategic Talent Partnership

The "Build vs. Buy" trap is a false choice based on an outdated, domestic-only model. Leading finance leaders are breaking this model by embracing a new, hybrid approach: the Strategic Global Talent Partner.

This isn't "outsourcing". It's a holistic model designed for building your global team. It gives you the speed and efficiency of a global model plus the high-touch integration and control of an in-house team. A good finance staffing agency does more than just fill a role. They help you find specialized talent worldwide, quickly. More importantly, they act as a true partner, ensuring your new hires integrate smoothly and your team succeeds for the long run.

This new way of building your team is defined by three core principles:

  • Performance-Driven Efficiency: This model leverages AI-smart sourcing and global talent pools to find the right talent for your team, cutting hiring time from months to weeks. The focus is on exceptional value and ROI, not just "low costs".
  • A True Extension of Your Team: It's built on a transparent model for everyone involved, not a "black box". Vetted professionals are embedded directly into your workflows and culture. They are in your meetings and on your Slack channels, working as one team under your direct management.
  • A Smarter, Ethical Foundation: This future-ready model is built on Fair Pay and B Corp principles. Why? Because the data is clear: fair compensation is the single greatest driver of talent retention, engagement and performance. This is how you attract and retain the skilled, motivated professionals you need.

This transformation for finance teams is complex and high-stakes, but the mandate is clear. The future of automation for accounting teams is not about replacing humans. It's about empowering them. The mandate is clear: to win with AI, you must first win with talent.

Q1. What skills matter most for my AI-powered finance team?

As AI handles routine data processing, the most critical skills become uniquely human. You need professionals who can act as true strategic partners. This includes critical thinking to question and validate AI outputs, data storytelling to translate complex findings into an actionable strategy for stakeholders, and strategic collaboration to integrate financial insights across the entire business. These "hybrid" skills are what turn AI's potential into measurable business outcomes.

Q2. The "Build vs. Buy" model is failing us. What's the alternative?

The "Build vs. Buy" trap is a false choice based on an outdated, domestic-only model. The alternative is a Strategic Global Talent Partner. This modern, hybrid approach builds your global team  by giving you the speed of AI-smart sourcing and the stability of an in-house team. It’s a transparent model —not a "black box"—where vetted professionals are embedded directly into your workflows, working as a valued extension of your team.

Q3. How is a "Strategic Talent Partnership" different from traditional outsourcing?

Traditional outsourcing is a transactional, "black box" service focused on "low cost". A Strategic Global Talent Partner builds you a resilient, high-performing team. Our model is built on Fair Pay and B Corp principles because the data is clear: this is the greatest driver of talent retention, motivation, and performance. This transparent model delivers exceptional value and a stable, engaged team that functions as a true part of your business.

Q4. Why is the ROI on our finance AI initiatives so low?

Many leaders see low ROI because they focus on the tech, not the team. AI automates routine tasks, which elevates the remaining human work to strategic interpretation, validation, and governance. This creates a new skills gap for "hybrid" roles that old recruitment models can't fill. Your AI's potential is stalled by a lack of human-centric skills. To win with AI, you must first build the right human team to manage it.

Work for Impact

Work for Impact

Posted on

18/11/2025